Chocolate chips and cocoa powder might not top your pantry staples list, but when Valentine’s Day, a potluck, or simply a sweet craving come along, you’ll be glad you have them on hand. But let’s face it: chocolate can be tricky. With so many different varieties it can be difficult to know what kind to buy or use. Our chocolate guide will save you time in the baking aisle and hopefully prevent you from making a disappointing batch of chocolate chip cookies (It can happen to anyone!).

Cocoa Powder

Cocoa powder is an ingredient we use in many of our decadent desserts for its deep, rich chocolate taste. There are two types of cocoa powder commonly used in baking, “Dutch processed” and “natural.” Dutch processed is cocoa powder that has been treated to make it less acidic. It is dark in color with a deep chocolate taste.  Natural cocoa powder is made from cocoa beans that have simply been roasted and ground, keeping the beans’ natural acidity. It is lighter in color than Dutch processed and has a brighter chocolate taste.

As a rule of thumb, for recipes that call for baking soda, use “natural” cocoa, and for recipes that call for baking powder, use “Dutch Processed.” This way the acidity of the cocoa is kept balanced.  If both baking powder and baking soda are used in a recipe, it is usually okay to use the two powders interchangeably, but because of the differences in acidity, it is usually in your best interest to stick with what the recipe calls for.

Never use powdered drinking chocolate for baking. It’s formulated to be mixed with liquid and contains a lot of sugar and dried milk solids.

Unsweetened/Bitter/Baking Chocolate

The common names for this chocolate really say it all. There is no sugar added, and it has a very bitter taste when eaten on its own. Its only use is for baking and making chocolate desserts where enough sugar and spices can be added to transform it into deliciousness. Bakers often prefer this chocolate because they have full control of the sugar content in a recipe. We recommend buying the best chocolate you can afford.

Bittersweet and Semi-Sweet Chocolate

Again, a bakers’ only chocolate. Bittersweet chocolate tends to have less sugar than semi-sweet chocolate, but they are often interchangeable in recipes.  Both names are used to describe either blocks of cooking chocolate or bagged chocolate chips. The package or store display will usually tell you what percentage of cacao they contain, so it is up to you how rich you want the chocolate to be. Again, we recommend buying the best chocolate you can afford.

Dark Chocolate

Finally, some chocolate you can eat!  This type of chocolate is sweetened with sugar and may have spices like vanilla added, but it does not contain any milk. If you like a rich dark chocolate flavor, dark chocolate is the bar for you. These days, many brands display the percentage of cacao on the packaging, so you can pick the one either with the highest content or the one you simply prefer.  Plus, good to know: dark chocolate is full of antioxidants that have been linked to heart health and other benefits.

Milk Chocolate

As the name implies, condensed milk or milk solids and sugar are added to dark chocolate to make this tasty treat, but the percentage of cacao is low compared to dark chocolate. In the US, it can be as little as 25%, and 35% in the EU. Baking recipes rarely call for milk chocolate, so if you are looking for a reason to keep it in your pantry, sorry, we cannot give you one! It is good as an occasional treat, though.

White Chocolate

The name here is a bit misleading. White chocolate does contain cocoa butter, but it does not have any chocolate liquor or any cacao, which is what makes true chocolate. White chocolate technically should have cocoa butter in it, but some brands market candy that uses vegetable oils instead of cocoa butter, so keep an eye on the ingredients.